The UPS 1354 pilot error accident serves as a powerful reminder of how quickly a routine approach can deteriorate into a Controlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT) event. In this case, the early-morning arrival occurred with 10 miles of visibility, a broken ceiling at 1,000 feet, and a fatigued crew attempting a non-precision localizer approach into Birmingham.
The weather briefing noted calm winds, visibility 10 miles, and a broken layer at 1,000 feet, but actual conditions were worse than reported. Compounding the challenge, Runway 6/24, where the crew had originally prepared a precision approach, was closed by NOTAM. Forced to switch to the shorter Runway 18 localizer-only approach, the pilots faced increased workload, reduced margins, and no vertical guidance.
The situation quickly became unstable as ATC kept the crew high on vectors, requiring a steep, rushed descent to intercept the localizer path. Non-precision approaches demand discipline and careful altitude management, but fatigue and frustration began eroding situational awareness.
Approach Setup, Errors, and Breakdown in Crew Resource Management (CRM)
Several key mistakes contributed to the UPS 1354 pilot error chain. Although the LNAV+V advisory guidance was loaded, it was never activated, leaving the aircraft without vertical profile assistance. With the aircraft kept high until late in the approach, the crew selected vertical speed mode and descended at 1,200-1,400 feet per minute, far steeper than recommended for a stable non-precision approach.
Crew Resource Management (CRM) deteriorated as the captain and first officer expressed frustration, focused on being kept high, and rushed to configure the aircraft. Multiple cues were missed or ignored:
- The minimums callout
- Excessive descent rates
- “Sink rate” warnings
- “Too low terrain” alerts
Even after spotting the runway, the aircraft was too low and too steep to recover safely. Impact occurred seconds later.
Key NTSB Findings and Lessons for Safer Flying
The NTSB identified six primary causes, including improper FMS configuration, poor communication, expectation bias, fatigue, and missing required callouts. Importantly, the report highlights how accidents rarely occur from a single cause. In the UPS 1354 pilot error scenario, fatigue, weather discrepancies, runway limitations, and high workload blended.
The key safety lesson is clear:If an approach becomes rushed, unstable, or requires excessive descent rates, a go-around is the safest decision. Even when operational pressure is high, early morning hours, freight schedules, or ATC accommodations, safety must remain the highest priority.
Start a Free Two-Week Trial at MzeroA
Love our videos and eager to learn more? Are you passionate about aviation, or curious to learn how to fly? Now’s the perfect time to explore further, with a 2-weel free trial of MzeroA’s Online Ground School. Take that “discovery flight” into MzeroA’s courses to see if we are the right fit for you!